Scrapbookpages Blog

April 30, 2010

Nazis put Moses Tobias in Dachau for trying to flee Germany.

Filed under: Dachau, Germany, Holocaust, World War II — Tags: , , , — furtherglory @ 8:06 am

I learn something new every day.  In today’s news, I read about a talk that College professor Sigmund Tobias  gave at the 27th annual Holocaust Commemoration in Holyoke, MA. The article was written by Mike Plaisance of The Republican and posted on the web site.  Sigmund Tobias told a group of Peck Middle School students that he “was 5 when the Nazis put his father Moses Tobias in Dachau for trying to flee Germany.”  I was always under the impression that the Nazis wanted the Jews to leave Germany, but apparently I was wrong.

According to the news article:

Authorities told the family the only way he could be freed was if they agreed to leave Berlin for the Japanese occupied section of Shanghai, China.

They lived there in a ghetto with 17,000 other Jewish refugees. It was one of the few places in the world willing to accept Jews fleeing Germany.

O.K. let me see if I understand this correctly: The Nazis put Moses Tobias into Dachau because he was trying to flee Germany, but then they told his family that the only way he could get out of the Dachau camp was if he agreed to leave Germany and go to Shanghai, China.

So the Nazis wouldn’t allow the German Jews to go to America in 1938?  That’s not the way I heard it.

Ten years ago, I went to visit the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington, DC.  The tour of the exhibits starts on the fourth floor where I saw a semicircular niche in the wall that was completely covered with a huge photograph of Lake Geneva. The title of this exhibit is “No help, No haven.” It is the story of the Evian Conference, which President Roosevelt organized in July 1938.

Representatives of 32 countries met at a luxury hotel to discuss the refugee problem after the Germans had taken over Austria in March and made it known that they wanted to get rid of all the Jews. Hitler jokingly offered to send all the German Jews on luxury liners to any country that would take them, but no country wanted the Jews.  America had laws at that time, which were intended to keep Jews out, but after the conference, America did agree to admit the full quota of Eastern Europeans and Germans allowed by our immigration laws, which had not been done up to that time.

An exhibit called  “Night of Broken Glass” is in the next section of the US Holocaust Memorial Museum. The museum uses the Polish word “pogrom” to characterize this event which happened on November 9, 1938. A pogrom is a state organized or state sanctioned riot in which Jewish property is destroyed, and the Jews are beaten and killed in an effort to force them to leave a town or province, or in this case, a country. The exhibit does not make it clear that pogroms had been a regular occurrence in Europe for at least a thousand years, and that this was the Mother of all Pogroms.

The caption of the USHMM exhibit mentions that the Jews were sent to the three main German concentration camps, Dachau, Sachsenhausen and Buchenwald, where they were released if they agreed to emigrate quickly. The caption does not say that they could only go to Shanghai, China. Moses Tobias was probably arrested on the Night of Broken Glass (Kristallnacht) and he was one of the 10,911 Jews who were sent to Dachau.

The news article continues with this quote:

“The Japanese didn’t have the personal animosity and hatred to the Jews that the Germans did,” Tobias said.

Still, he said, while Japan resisted Germany’s demand that it execute the Jews, life in the ghetto was a struggle.

So the Nazis demanded that the Japanese kill the Jews for them?  But the Japanese resisted?  Like I said, I learn something new every day.

Another quote from the news article:

He showed slides of a trip to Dachau, which was destroyed but has been rebuilt, including the Nazi ovens.

I didn’t know that Dachau was destroyed and then rebuilt. I always thought that the “Nazi ovens” at Dachau were original, but I guess I was wrong.

According to the news article:

He read from his 1999 book, Strange Haven: A Jewish Childhood in Wartime Shanghai. Dolores R. Stein, of Holyoke, said that in the face of Holocaust deniers, such remembrances are necessary for each generation.


  1. Can someone explain how it was proposed to transit from Berlin to Shanghai at that time and who would supervise that transit?

    Comment by Wolfgang — May 4, 2010 @ 8:39 am

    • Shanghai was the only place that the Jews could enter without a visa. Each individual Jew in Germany had to arrange their own transportation to Shanghai and go there on their own. The families of the Berlin Jews had to make the arrangements while the Jews were being held at Buchenwald, Dachau and Sachsenhausen after Kristallnacht on November 9, 1938.

      Comment by furtherglory — May 4, 2010 @ 9:00 am

      • ‘Each individual Jew in Germany had to arrange their own transportation to Shanghai and go there on their own.’ – On a sea voyage embarking Hamburg to the Far East or by rail. Its a remarkable journey either way.

        I’ve just read a document regarding the Evian Conference where the US and others agreed to recieve European Jews from Austria and Germany which contradicts the statement that Shanghai was the only place they could go (visa or no visa). Any ideas on the numbers we are talking that emigrated in that window of opportunity?

        Comment by Wolfgang — May 4, 2010 @ 12:47 pm

        • America had an annual quota of 25,957 immigrants from Germany, both Jews and non-Jews. This quota was set in a law passed by Congress in 1921. In the 6 years before the Evian conference, America had only allowed 27,000 German immigrants into the country. After the Evian Conference, America began allowing 25,957 German immigrants into the country. The Dominican Republic agreed to take 100,000 German Jews, but only 5,000 went there. Visas were required to get into the USA or the Dominican Republic. Shanghai was an open city where anyone could enter without a visa.

          Comment by furtherglory — May 4, 2010 @ 10:19 pm

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

%d bloggers like this: