Scrapbookpages Blog

September 20, 2012

Holocaust Education comes to Hermann, MO

Filed under: Germany, Holocaust — Tags: , , , — furtherglory @ 10:18 am

This morning, I read a news article on the online Columbia Missourian newspaper, which you can read in full here.

This quote is from the article:

[Elie Wiesel’s book] “Night is crucial to me,” said Flynn.  It was the first Holocaust novel she taught when she began teaching in Hermann.

What’s wrong with that?  Why shouldn’t students in Hermann, MO be taught the Holocaust, the same as students in every other school in America?  At least, the book “Night” is being taught as a novel in the classrooms in Hermann.

This website tells you about the town of Hermann, MO.  It is a town that was established by a group of German immigrants who traveled by wagon train to Missouri in 1839 and founded a town, populated entirely by ethnic Germans.

As a child, I lived in another small town in Missouri that was mostly German-American, but it was nothing like the town of Hermann, which had a population that was exclusively Volkdeutsch. Our High School basketball team played the Hermann team, but we could never win — not against those blond, blue-eyed Übermenschen.

The Holocaust didn’t happen in America and the German-Americans in Missouri were not responsible for it.  Now the ethnic Germans in Herman are being taught that they must forever hang their heads in shame because of what happened in Germany more than 70 years ago.

Do the students in Hermann, MO have just one class on the Holocaust and then get back to studying American history and German history?  No, it goes on and on, year after year; the students have “progressive lessons” on the Holocaust.

This quote is from the article in the Columbia Missourian:

Progressive Lessons

Still, Flynn said one of the advantages of the program is teachers know what knowledge students gain from year to year so they don’t have to go back to the beginning.

“It makes everybody’s job a little bit easier and we avoid some of the Holocaust fatigue,” Flynn said.

She’s planned out lessons for seventh, eighth and ninth grade English students. When selecting the reading material she considered students’ maturity levels and bore in mind students’ realize the atrocity of Hitler’s final solution better when learning about individuals in their same age group affected by the Holocaust.

As a preview to the novel “Friedrich” by Hans Peter Richter, seventh-graders will study the social and cultural conditions that allowed the Nazis to become the ruling party of Germany. The book about two boys, one of whom is Jewish, growing up in Germany during the 1930s and, 40s is historical fiction.

Eighth-grade topics will include a closer view of life for Jews in hiding or captivity. Flynn determined books for their Holocaust unit would likely be “Surviving the Angel of Death” by Eva Mozes Kor and “The Diary of Anne Frank.”

Kor’s memoir about living through torture and experimentation at the hands of Dr. Joseph Mengele was adapted for a young adult audience and Flynn prefers the real diary over the lightly embellished play.

Shown in the photo below are some of the 611 Jewish children in the Auschwitz-Birkenau camp when it was liberated. The girl on the far right is one of the Moses twins who were forced to be the subjects of medical experiments done by Dr. Josef Mengele. Miriam and her sister Eva Mozes Kor both survived; Auschwitz-Birkenau was liberated four days before their 11th birthday.

The child on the far right is Miriam Moses

In the photo below, the child on the far right is one of the Moses twins. Miriam Moses died in 1995, after battling cancer and kidney disease, which Eva Moses Kor says stemmed from her treatment at Auschwitz.

The child on the far right is Eva Moses Kor

The quote from the Columbia Missourian continues below:

Flynn said the ninth-grade experience will be more immersive (sic) since they will address death marches and killing centers. Students will read “Night,” the devastating account of how Elie Weisel, a Nobel Peace Prize laureate, lost his family and innocence as a teenager in Auschwitz.

So the ninth-graders in Hermann, MO will learn about the “death marches and killing centers.”

Will the students be allowed to ask questions?  For example, why did the Jews have to be “death marched” out of the “killing centers?”  Was it because there had not been enough time to kill them at the killing centers, so that they had to be marched to death?  That is the official Holocaust story: the prisoners were marched out of the camps, as a means of killing them, so that they would not be able to testify about what they had seen in the camps.

One of the prisoners, who was marched out of Auschwitz, was Elie Wiesel, who didn’t die on the death march.  He was taken to the Buchenwald camp where he wasn’t killed; he was allowed to live and write a book about the atrocities that he had seen at Auschwitz.

Will the students in Hermann, MO learn about the German-Americans who were put into internment camps in America, and kept there for two years after the war ended?  Probably not.

To me, teaching German-American students about the Holocaust is like putting them in internment camps again. World War II is over and the German people are no longer the enemy.  Enough already!

5 Comments »

  1. It’s official. Obama really does say the three great religions are Islam, Christianity and the Holocaust.
    http://www.nationaljournal.com/whitehouse/full-text-president-obama-s-speech-at-the-united-nations-general-assembly-20120925

    Comment by who dares wings — October 1, 2012 @ 9:32 am

  2. Sorry for the typos. Writing on a touchscreen phone keyboard. Just in case somebody thinks I am uneducated

    Comment by Tim — September 20, 2012 @ 7:24 pm

  3. Night is classified as fiction. Fiction is being taught as fact. The detail about babies burning alive in an open fire is something Wiesel made up for maximum shock value.

    I don’t want my kids to have a curriculum where they are bombarded with propaganda. What about the real babies burned in their cribs by Allied bombing? The great city of Dresden completely bombed off the planet. The post war POWs used as slave labor, almost a million who starved to death. Many were even civilians. What about the Germans expelled from Danzig and other traditionally German areas? Germany destroyed, looted, partitioned. Where is the moral equivalency? Why is illegal to question the any aspect of the holocaust? There are excellent questions being asked and not out of hate. Those who live in a place where they are allowed to ask are harassed. Nobody addresses the questions. This breeds doubt and I have doubt about the most horrific aspects due to the absurdity of eyewitness testimony, often the only evidence.

    And what the Allies did to the German people after the war… Nobody writes of it. Western academics avoid it. Where is the moral equivalency? German Americans along with Japanes Americans were encamped. Their possessions take away. A British-run camp treated German POWs inhumanly compared to Dachau, as mentioned in at least one report.

    Why this unnatural and obsessive focus on the holocaust in our children’s formative years? Why so many Holocaust mesuems? Americans had nothing to do with the holocaust. It didn’t happen on American soil. We don’t have memorials honoring the wartime dead caused by another country in another country.

    The subject it taboo and makes others emotional and uncomfortable, but after 30 years of no doubt I am convinced something is very wrong. These kids shouldn’t be taught this until they are older. They are brainwashing them for some unknown reason.

    Comment by Tim — September 20, 2012 @ 7:20 pm

  4. As you know furtherglory, Americans of German-ancestry are always only a goose-step away from finishing what started in the old country.
    https://furtherglory.wordpress.com/2012/09/10/republican-congressman-invokes-the-holocaust-in-a-speech-about-student-loans/

    In 2007 an American of German ancestry attempted to gas Elie Wiesel in a hotel elevator.

    Comment by The Black Rabbit of Inlé — September 20, 2012 @ 7:01 pm

  5. Our German exchange students were ‘shamed’ by what happened. We tried to explain that it was not their fault.

    Comment by shermangerherd — September 20, 2012 @ 11:42 am


RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: