Scrapbookpages Blog

July 17, 2016

tear down this eyesore

Filed under: Germany, Holocaust — furtherglory @ 11:26 am

Remember when Ronald Reagan said “Mr. Gorbachev, tear down this wall

It is time for someone, maybe Donald Trump, to say, with regard to the Berlin monument, shown in the photo below: “tear down this eyesore.”

Monument to the Jews in Berlin

Monument to the Jews in the heart of Berlin

Completed memorial covers 5 and a half acres

Berlin Memorial covers 5 and a half acres Photo Credit: Bonnie M. Harris

My 2002 photo of the location of the monument

My 2002 photo of the location of the monument just before it was built

The following article was sent to me in 2002 by Bonnie M. Harris; she gave me permission to publish the article, which is quoted below:

HOLOCAUST MEMORIAL BERLIN
A personal perspective by Bonnie M. Harris

As a PhD candidate in Public History at the University of California, Santa Barbara, I recently completed a month-long tour of Holocaust sites in Poland, The Czech Republic, Austria, and Germany while performing archival research into the Polenaktion of October 28, 1938. During my research trip to Berlin, I took the occasion to visit the new Holocaust Memorial in the center of the city.

I had read several reviews about the memorial just after it had been constructed in 2005, so I was prepared to see a massive field of stone pillars meant to convey and incite emotions in the viewers about the Holocaust through an abstract artistic approach. As I came upon the memorial from the corner of Ebertstrasse and Hannah-Arendtstrasse, my initial reaction as I looked across the entire area was one of disappointment.

The field of stele first appeared small and insignificant and I did not see how this city block of rectangular concrete slabs could possibly impress me. But as I entered the memorial my perception began to change. At first, the stele were barely inches in height, but as I continued to walk the concrete paths between the slabs, suddenly the ground plunged down and the steles were soon well over my head ­ a fact I could not know or see from where I first stood when I looked over the site. As I continued to walk paths without any forethought as to where I would end up, the ground rose and fell in a random undulation, and the stele towered above me and cut off my vision of the horizon and the sounds of life in the city.

One path looked very much like another and a sense of direction was impossible to maintain. Even as I saw other people pass in and out of my vision as they trespassed the paths of the memorial just as I did, I had this unnatural feeling of being alone and disconnected from all others. I emerged from the forest of concrete on the opposite side of where I had entered and as I looked back on the field of stele, I saw a completely different visual portrayal of the site. I now saw shadows that demarcated height and depth to the field, with variations in angles and slopes. And I could barely see those who still wandered among the stone giants, only catching glimpses as they walked in and out of my field of sight. I realized that what I had just experienced taught me an important lesson about the Holocaust.

Those of us, who only approach the experience of the Holocaust from the peripheral historical facts, will never be able to fully understand the perceptions and sufferings of those who actually lived through it ­ who actually walked its paths. And even those of us who do all that we can to try to learn about the Holocaust through the testimonies of those who survived, we will never be able to walk the same path and feel exactly what they felt, because each experience is as individual as each stone slab in the field of 2711.

Even though they may appear the same from the outside, as the Nazis tried to strip all individuality from their victims, the stones are of varying heights, with varying degrees of slant, shading, color, and reflection. Individualities still existed among the Holocaust victims and to a great degree it was the randomness of individuality that allowed some to survive and a great many to die.

I also learned that once you have immersed yourself in Holocaust education by trying to internalize the testimonies of the witnesses and by becoming a witness yourself by seeing the camps, the gas chambers, the ovens, the burial sites and other places of death and torture that can now only be memorialized, your perception forever changes and you now have a clearer understanding of what the Holocaust really was and how it impacted personal lives and family dynamics, as well as an entire culture’s identity and international societal ethics.

End quote

 

5 Comments »

  1. “tear down this eyesore”

    No! Don’t! Let everybody see how ugly & sordid the Jewish mind is…

    Comment by hermie — July 19, 2016 @ 1:42 pm

  2. Bonnie M. Harris is described as a PhD “candidate” in Public History at the University of California. So I suppose – as part of her syllabus – she was required to write all this guff and twaddle about the hideously ugly, and spectacularly meaningless Berlin Holocaust Memorial, in order to be awarded her full doctorate.

    She wrote;- ” I realized that what I had just experienced taught me an important lesson about the Holocaust ”

    Do you know something, that’s exactly what happened to me and my companion when we visited the memorial a little while back. He had climbed up on one of the taller concrete blocks to get a good photo shot of the site, but before he could even press the shutter, a furious, uniformed, gestapo lady arrived; blew her whistle loudly; started gesticulating; and ordered him to get down immediately.

    So we both learned three important lessons about the Holocaust that day;- 1) You always obey the commands of the Holocaust officials and their enforcers; 2) You never show any initiative yourself, or carry out any independent act that might challenge the status quo; and 3) The “Bitch of Buchenwald” is still very much alive and well in Germany today !

    Comment by Talbot — July 18, 2016 @ 1:34 am

    • You wrote: “a furious, uniformed, gestapo lady arrived; blew her whistle loudly; started gesticulating; and ordered him to get down immediately.”

      The Germans are noted for being very strict on law and order.
      That woman was there to protect the blocks in the monument. If one of the blocks had to be replaced, it would not match the other blocks and the design would be ruined. Besides that, your companion could have fallen off the block and broken his leg.

      Comment by furtherglory — July 18, 2016 @ 6:09 am

  3. It used to be gardens at the back of Willhelmstrasse. I think it needs to converted back to gardens and I hope it will be within the next fifty years. You might think this fanciful but
    events are often unpredictable eg the fall of the Berlin wall and the British departure from the European Union.

    Comment by peter — July 17, 2016 @ 5:07 pm

  4. I agree tearing it down would be great or using it as some sort of free wheeling skate park.

    JR

    Comment by jrizoli — July 17, 2016 @ 11:58 am


RSS feed for comments on this post.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: