Scrapbookpages Blog

June 10, 2011

“… there is a Hitler in every human being!”

Filed under: Holocaust — Tags: , , , — furtherglory @ 9:06 am

“If you would only know that there is a Hitler in every human being!”

These words were spoken to Dr. Elizabeth Kübler-Ross by a Holocaust survivor whom she met, as a young girl from Switzerland, on a visit to the site of the Majdanek (Maidanek) death camp in Poland in 1945. The former Majdanek camp was turned into a museum by the Soviet Union very soon after it was liberated in July 1944.  I didn’t know that young girls from Switzerland were brought there for tours in 1945 — but I learn something new every day.

Dr. Kübler-Ross told about her visit to Maidanek in an interview conducted by Dr. Daniel Redwood, which you can read in full here.

This quote is from Dr. Redwood’s interview with Dr. Kübler-Ross:

This young woman had lost all her brothers and sisters, parents and grandparents in a gas chamber. She was the last one they tried to squash in, and there wasn’t room for one more person, so they pulled her out. What she didn’t understand was that she had already been crossed off the list of the living. They never got back to her. She spent the rest of the war years in this concentration camp swearing that she would stay alive to tell the world about all the atrocities that she witnessed.

When the people came to liberate the camp, she said to herself, “Oh my God, if I spend the rest of my life telling about all these horrible things, I would not be any better than Hitler himself. I would plant seeds of hate and negativity.” She made at that moment a promise to whoever she talked to, God presumably, that she would stay in the concentration camp until she could learn to forgive even a Hitler. When she had learned that lesson, then she would be worthy of leaving. Do you understand that?

[...]

That was the beginning of my journey. When I went back to Switzerland, I said I’m going to study medicine, and I’m going to understand why people, from beautiful, innocent, gorgeous children, turn into Nazi monsters.

I have read about other Holocaust survivors who were saved when they were thrown out of a gas chamber because the room was too full, but I didn’t know until now why they were not taken to the gas chamber again on another day.  According to this survivor of the Majdanek camp, it was because names were crossed off the death list when the victims were taken to the gas chamber and when someone was thrown out of the gas chamber at the last minute, the “Nazi monsters” never got back to them.   The gas chamber lists were never found when the camps were liberated; all the gas chamber records were apparently destroyed and the names of the Jews who were gassed are unknown.

Here is another quote from the very beginning of the interview:

Elisabeth Kubler-Ross Interview

DR: What has led you to devote so much of your time, skill and attention to issues of death and dying?

ELISABETH KUBLER-ROSS: It started in Maidanek, in a concentration camp, where I tried to see how children had gone into the gas chambers after having lost their families, their homes, their schools and everything. The walls in the camp were filled with pictures of butterflies, drawn by these children.

It was incomprehensible to me. Thousands of children going into the gas chamber, and this is the message they leave behind–a butterfly. That was really the beginning.

In this concentration camp there was a Jewish girl, and she watched me. I hope you understand, I was a very young kid naturally, who hadn’t gone through any windstorms in life. When you grow up in Switzerland, there is no race problem, no poverty, no unemployment, no slums, no nothing. And I went right into the nightmare of postwar Europe.

So I asked her, how can men and women, like you and I, kill hundreds and thousands of innocent children, and the same day they do that, day after day, they worry about their own child at home who has chicken pox. It just didn’t compute in my brain, you know, being very innocent and ignorant.

When I visited the Memorial Site at the former Majdanek camp, I was surprised to see all the artwork on display; there were sculptures and lots of other artwork that had been done by the prisoners in the camp. I remember a rosary that had been fashioned out of bits of bread that had been wadded up and left to dry to make the beads. I did not see the butterfly pictures, but perhaps they had been taken to another Holocaust Museum in America or Israel for display.

The children in the Theresienstadt (Terezin) concentration camp were allowed to do artwork and they were even given lessons in drawing and painting by an adult teacher.  Some of their pictures were on display at the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington, DC when I visited there years ago.

But to get back to the “Nazi monsters.”  Hitler was an artist himself.  Is that why he allowed the children to draw or paint butterflies before they were killed in the gas chamber?  Hitler may have thought that he was being kind to the innocent children by allowing them to paint butterflies before dying, but I think this was unnecessarily cruel.  It gave the children hope, when there was none.

This quote from the interview shows how Dr. Kübler-Ross finally realized that there is a Hitler in all of us:

And I thought, “She is crazy, I don’t have a Hitler in me.” A few days later, I hitchhiked back to Switzerland, because I was very sick. I was near death. I never made it. They found me unconscious in a forest in Germany, with typhoid. But before I ended up in a hospital (I was picked up half dead in a forest, unconscious), I had been so hungry. I had no food in my stomach for three days and three nights. I suddenly realized in the midst of this hike, that if a small child would walk by me with a piece of bread in its hands, I would steal that piece of bread from that child’s hand.

Typhoid is caused by drinking contaminated water.  When I visited Poland, I was advised to drink only bottled water.  Not wanting to take any chances, I even brushed by teeth with the bottled water that was supplied in my hotel room.  Did young girls from Switzerland throw all caution to the wind by drinking tap water in Poland in 1945?  Probably.  Keep in mind that, as a young girl, Dr. Kübler-Ross tried to HITCH-HIKE back to Switzerland from the Majdanek camp, which is in the city of Lublin near the Eastern border of Poland. That was a very foolish thing to do in 1945.  Why did a tour leader allow that?  Or did she go to Poland, which was behind “the Iron Curtain,” by herself in 1945?

In any case, this experience helped her to understand Hitler.  She would have stolen bread from a child when she got hungry while walking through a forest in Germany if she had been given the chance.  Hitler was blinded by mustard gas when he was a soldier in World War I. Was that how he got the idea of gassing little children, after first allowing them to draw butterflies?

In doing a search to find the obituary of Dr. Kübler-Ross, I came across this website which has a conversation between the doctor and John Harricharan who knew her personally.  I learned that Dr. Kübler-Ross died at the age of 78 in 2004.  That means that she was born in 1926; she was one of triplets. She told Harricharan that she left home at the age of 15 with nothing but a backpack.  She said that she was from a wealthy family, but nevertheless, her parents allowed her to leave home at this young age.  Or did she run away from home during war-time?

Here is the exact quote from her interview with John Harricharan:

At the age of 15 I left home to find myself. World War II was raging and the Nazis were leaving millions of people dead or dying in their wake. Cities were being destroyed, people were starving, children separated from their parents–an unimaginable horror of man’s inhumanity to man. I wanted to help, to heal, feed and clothe the less fortunate. So, with others, I did what I could, I was led from those experiences to what I am doing today.
[...]
All I had was my backpack and a few personal possessions. Even though I was born relatively well-off and had a very comfortable life, I gave it all up for the sake of being with those who needed help.

[...]
Remember, I was still a young girl when all this happened. I saw refugees from Germany trying to get over to Switzerland mowed down by machine guns. Traveling through Europe, I did all I could to help feed people. I love relief work! I helped rebuild villages in France, moved on to Belgium and hitchhiked to Poland.

Note that she hitchhiked TO Poland.  I thought that she went on a tour and hitchhiked BACK to Switzerland. Note also that she saw refugees trying to get into Switzerland and being mowed down by machine guns.  Who was manning these machine guns — German or Swiss citizens?  Germany had lost the war and was then occupied.  It must have been the Swiss that were mowing down refugees.

Then she tells the story again about how she met a Holocaust survivor whose whole family had been gassed.  I had assumed that this woman was Jewish, but in her talk with John Harricharan, Dr. Kübler-Ross indicated that the woman was a Polish non-Jew.  Dr. Kübler-Ross explained that she had met this woman when the survivor walked three days through the Polish countryside to find her so that she could cure her one remaining child who had typhoid.   Elizabeth Kübler was a young girl at that time, not yet a medical doctor.

Dr. Kübler-Ross walked with the woman and her child to a place that served as a clinic.  This quote explains what happened then:

There was nothing I could do. We had no antibiotics, no medicine, no anything. I told the woman it was hopeless and that her child would die. She pleaded with me saying, “This is the last of my 13 children. You must save him!” “It is easy to say that,” I replied, “but there is very little I can do. What happened to the others?” With a quivering voice she told me how all her other children, her brothers and sisters, father, mother and grandparents were wiped out in a concentration camp. She ended by saying, “So you see, Mrs. Doctor, (that’s what they called me), you must save this last one.”

The child recovered and the mother came back to find Elizabeth Kübler, who told Harricharan that she always slept in a cemetery, which she considered the only safe place to sleep back then.  Then one day, she was awakened by the mother and her child.

This quote continues the story:

As I opened my eyes I noticed a handkerchief with something in it and a piece of paper. Inside was some black soil and a note written in pencil which read, “Mrs. Doctor, this is blessed Polish soil from Mrs. W. whose last of 13 children you saved.”

This woman must have walked days to the hospital, found her child alive, walked back to her village for the soil, then to the priest to have him bless it, and finally, back to me at the camp. The whole trip must have taken almost a week of walking, It was the best gift I’ve ever received in my entire life. I never saw the woman again but that incident is as clear as ever in my mind, and it had a profound effect on my future.

Note that the woman had soil from her village blessed by a priest.  This indicates that she was probably not Jewish.  Yet, her whole family had been gassed and she had survived only because the gas chamber was full that day.

It is not clear, from this interview with Harricharan, which gas chamber the woman was talking about.  As the interview continues, Dr. Kübler-Ross starts talking about Auschwitz.

This quote from the interview with Harricharan mentions Auschwitz:

Later I went to visit the concentration camps. I saw trainloads of children’s shoes. They were the shoes of the children who were sent to the gas chambers. I remember standing there wondering how we could kill each other, destroy so much, and still worry about whether our children have chicken pox or a toothache? It was difficult for me to understand. So I asked a woman who was standing next to me and she said, ” You too, are capable of doing that.” I disagreed vehemently.

Then I started thinking: if the Nazis were raised in Switzerland, they might have been different, and if I had been raised in Germany, I too could have been like them. Who was I to judge anyone? I realized that there is a Hitler in all of us, but if we seek out and find that Hitler and get rid of him, we can become a Mother Theresa.

And I wanted to know more about these children. I found messages from them scratched into the walls with their fingernails. Messages to their moms and dads. But they also drew pictures of butterflies. There were no butterflies at Auschwitz and I always wondered what made these children draw butterflies and then fearlessly walk into the gas chambers. The woman I met there taught me forgiveness. Boy, did I learn a lot from her! She had hated the Germans but turned around and forgave them.

Note that she went to visit “the concentration camps (plural).”  There are shoes on display at both Majdanek and Auchwitz.  It is clear that these shoes have been exposed to Zyklon-B because they are deteriorating.  The leather suitcases at Auschwitz are not deteriorating.

Dr. Kübler-Ross mentioned that “There were no butterflies at Auschwitz.”  Butterflies are attracted by certain kinds of flowers.  There were flowers at Auschwitz, according to my Jewish tour guide who told me this when I visited the camp in 1998, but roses don’t attract butterflies.

Note that she said, “they also drew pictures of butterflies.”  This leads me to believe that she saw some of the pictures drawn by the children at Theresienstadt who were later sent to Auschwitz.  She also said that she “found messages from them scratched into the walls with their fingernails.”  The walls of what?  I think she is referring to the scratches on the walls of the gas chamber, not the barracks.  I have read stories on other web sites about scratches on the walls of the gas chamber at Majdanek, but I didn’t see them when I was there in 1998.

Note that she said, “if the Nazis were raised in Switzerland, they might have been different, and if I had been raised in Germany, I too could have been like them.”  So at least, she does not think that the Germans carry bad genes, as some people allege.  Presumably, the ethnic Germans in Switzerland are alright.  So who was machine-gunning those refugees?

14 Comments »

  1. @ Ethelred.
    Your quote:
    “Apart from strokes I wonder how many of the contradictions between survivor accounts can be ascribed to ‘Flase memory Syndrome’.
    Answer:
    All of them.

    Comment by Gasan — June 15, 2011 @ 9:09 pm

  2. Apart from strokes I wonder how many of the contradictions between survivor accounts can be ascribed to ‘Flase memory Syndrome’. If you go through a lot of stress, bury some of your memories but hear others accounts then when the memories come back how pure are they?

    Comment by Ethelred — June 12, 2011 @ 3:06 am

  3. Elizabeth Kübler-Ross probably read or saw an early copy of I Never Saw Another Butterfly and added butterflies to her Majdanek reminiscence for maximum effect. She was one of dozens of “pop” psychologists and psychiatrists whose New Age ideas were popularized in the Sixties. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I_Never_Saw_Another_Butterfly

    I Never saw Another Butterfly, and the play based on it, is second only to The Diary of Anne Frank in it’s use as a Holocaust teaching tool in the American elementary and middle school systems. It’s gone through many printings, but I haven’t been able to find dates for the first edition. Trading on Guilt: Holocaust Education in the Public School System by Philip Glidden is the story of what happened to one father who questioned the mandatory exposure of his child to tax subsidized Judeocentric atrocity propaganda. http://www.amazon.com/Trading-guilt-Holocaust-education-schools/dp/0739203223/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1307809666&sr=1-1

    Comment by who+dares+wings — June 11, 2011 @ 9:44 am

  4. Kubler-Ross was born in July 1926, so she was 19 years old in 1945. You, FG, said she was a “young girl from Switzerland” when she visited Maidanek and talked to the young woman there who “lost all her famiy in the gas chamber.” At 19, she was not a ‘young girl’, not even a girl, but a ‘young woman.’

    I understand how you got this idea, since Kubler-Ross said herself to the interviewer, ” I was a very young kid naturally, who hadn’t gone through any windstorms in life.” I said in previous comment she was a liar. She’s sure not telling the truth when she says she was a “very young kid” at age 19. (She may have had a sheltered life, but most of us do, but we’re still pretty mature even earlier than 19.) This put the idea into your head that she was “a young girl,” so you see how easily we accept what people with well-known reputations say and how careless THEY can be in giving wrong impressions.

    Does anybody in the general population (apart from here, now) ever think to question whether there were really butterflies painted all over the walls? Doubt it. Yet that is also something that probably got changed over time in Kubler-Ross’ memory. So I have to now give you credit, FG, for helping us to uncover this good example of the faulty memories of these upstanding, GOOD individuals like K-R. Never believe what is said by ANYONE without checking it out. The Jews, like the girl at Maidanek, demand to be believed. We have to tell them straight out: Prove it!

    Comment by Skeptic — June 11, 2011 @ 9:23 am

    • I have since done more research on this subject and I have updated my blog post. Scroll down to see the Update. I learned that Kubler-Ross suffered several strokes. I know from personal experience that a stroke can affect one’s memory. She obviously got her memories mixed up. Just yesterday, when someone asked me where I live, I gave my address from 30 years ago, but then quickly corrected myself. So I can understand that she couldn’t remember where she saw the butterfly pictures years ago.

      Comment by furtherglory — June 11, 2011 @ 10:38 am

  5. “Of the 1.6 million prisoners who passed through the Nazi concentration camp system in its twelve-year existence, 1.1 million died. Of those fatalities, more than 250,000, or a quarter, perished during the last five months of the regime” – Christopher Browning

    This is the lead sentence in a review entitled “Hunting Zebras” of Daniel Blatman’s new book The Death Marches in the June 3 issue of The Times Literary Supplement . Further on Browning writes, “In March 1945, Himmler complicated the situation further by sending out contradictory directives as to whether camp prisoners should be evacuated, liquidated or left alive and in place to be liberated by Allied troops….However, at least initially, he did not pass on Hitler’s directive that no prisoners were to be left alive to fall into Allied hands.”

    Excuse me, but isn’t Mr. Browning a bit off on his Holomath and making this Hitler directive up out of whole cloth? The letters to the editor in the next issue of TLS should be pretty entertaining because the pilpul (Talmudic hairsplitting) over Holocaust historiography and the accusations of anti-Semitism regularly argued over there is one reason why I continue to subscribe to this pompous rag.

    Comment by who+dares+wings — June 11, 2011 @ 8:28 am

    • The plaques at Auschwitz-Birkenau say that 1.1 million died at Auschwitz. According to Browning, no one died in any of the other camps, if a total of 1.1 died in “the Nazi concentration system.” How many were killed by the Einsatzgruppen? According to Browning’s statement, 4.9 million had to have been killed in other places besides the camps, if a total of 6 million were killed. Didn’t he write a book about the Einsatzgruppen? I think that might have been one of the books that I threw out of my home library.

      Hitler DID say that “no prisoners were to be left alive to fall into Allied hands.” He was talking about the Sachsenhausen camp. I wrote about the evacuation of the Sachsenhausen camp on my web site:

      http://www.scrapbookpages.com/Sachsenhausen/ConcentrationCamp/Death%20March.html

      It seems that Browning has twisted Hitler’s order to give it a different meaning.

      Browning also twisted the meaning of the Dachau order when he wrote this: “In March 1945, Himmler complicated the situation further by sending out contradictory directives as to whether camp prisoners should be evacuated, liquidated or left alive and in place to be liberated by Allied troops….However, at least initially, he did not pass on Hitler’s directive that no prisoners were to be left alive to fall into Allied hands.”

      I wrote about the Himmler order on my web site:

      http://www.scrapbookpages.com/DachauScrapbook/DachauLiberation/Background.html

      Here is a quote of the pertinent part about the Dachau evacuation on my web site:

      Begin quote
      On that same day, the 14th of April, Reichsführer-SS Heinrich Himmler authorized SS Colonel Kurt Becher to negotiate the surrender of Dachau and other camps to the Allies because conditions in the overcrowded camps were now totally out of control. Becher had previously been involved in negotiating with the Allies in the infamous “Blood for Goods” deal in which the Nazis offered to trade a million Hungarian Jews for 10,000 trucks.

      Allegedly, Himmler immediately rescinded his order in a note hurriedly written by hand on plain paper, dated 14 April 1945 and 18 April 1945. The hand-written note from Himmler is now stored in the files of the International Red Cross Tracing Service and news of the existence of the note was released to the public in March 2007.

      The note which was signed “Heinrich Himmler, Reichsführer SS” read as follows:

      A handover is out of the question. The camp must be evacuated immediately. No prisoner must be allowed to fall into the hands of the enemy alive. The prisoners have behaved horribly to the civilian population of Buchenwald.

      Buchenwald was the name of a concentration camp, not the name of a town, and there was no “civilian population of Buchenwald,” which Himmler, of all people, should have known. There were around 25,000 prisoners at Dachau at that point, and thousands more arriving every day, as the prisoners from the sub-camps were brought to the main camp. Keeping this mass of prisoners out of the “hands of the enemy” would have been virtually impossible.

      Arthur Haulot, a Belgian political prisoner at Dachau, wrote in his diary that he heard about this order, one hour after it arrived in Dachau, allegedly by telex. Haulot referred to the order as a “pessimistic rumor.” He had heard about it from a German nurse in the camp, who was his lover.

      However, Marcus J. Smith wrote in his book “Dachau: The Harrowing of Hell” that the Dachau main camp had no telephone or telegraph service on April 27, 1945 so that acting Commandant Weiss was unable to contact headquarters in Oranienburg for permission to allow a Red Cross man to enter the camp; Weiss was forced to give permission on his own authority. The lack of telephone and telegraph service was due to damage caused by the Allied bombing of the camp on April 9, 1945, so presumably there was no telegraph service on April 14th or 18th.
      End Quote

      Comment by furtherglory — June 11, 2011 @ 11:10 am

  6. From an obituary in ‘The Guardian’ which may provide clairifcation on a couple of points.

    “…she…then volunteered as a relief worker. She visited a Nazi concentration camp in Poland after the end of the war and saw, on the blighted barrack walls, hundreds of images of butterflies, a symbol of rebirth amid mass deaths. The experience left a profound impression. ”

    This was several months after the Soviet liberated the camp. Was the young woman maintained by them to talk to visitors? – is that what she meant by ‘staying in the camp’? At this time the Soviet Authorities were claiming that the numbers gassed here was much higher than current figure. Is there any evidence that whole families were gassed at Majdanek ?

    This is not in any way to question Elizabeth Kubler Ross’s sincerity or the good she may have done, or indeed that people were killed there.

    Comment by Ethelred — June 11, 2011 @ 1:47 am

    • The barracks at Majdanek are made of unpainted wood. They are pre-fabricated horse barns. I didn’t go into all of the barracks; I only went into the ones that were on exhibit. It was fairly dark inside and I did not see any “images of butterflies.” It is not clear in the obituary whether the buttlerflies were painted directly on the walls or on a canvas or piece of paper. I went there with a guide, who should have known whether the butterflies were still there, but she didn’t mention them at all.

      I had to look up the word blighted to verify the meaning of the word. Just as I thought, the word blighted is only used in reference to plants. I remember a Beatrix Potter poem which has the lines:

      We love our little garden,
      And tend it with such care,
      You will not find a faded leaf
      Or blighted blossom there.

      I interpreted “staying in the camp” to mean that the survivor was at Majdanek as a tour guide. The Museum at Majdanek currently gives the number of deaths at Majdanek as 78,000, of which 59,000 were Jews. The number that was given by the Soviet Union was 1.5 million deaths with no mention of how many Jews were killed. These figures include all deaths. There are no figures on how many were gassed. It is my understanding that whole families were never gassed at the same time; the men and women were gassed separately and the children went with the mothers. Remember that the gas chambers were disguised as shower rooms and the men and women would not have showered together. Majdanek has a reconstructed gas chamber that is a shower room.

      Comment by furtherglory — June 11, 2011 @ 6:35 am

  7. FG, I have to say this is not one of your better blogs. It’s ridiculous, really. Why pretend to take these people seriously? Why not just directly point out how stupid are the things they say. This “holocaust survivor” who was “pulled out of the gas chamber” is never named. Obviously she never existed. Therefore, Kubler-Ross is a liar and this Dr. Daniel Redwood is an accomplice.

    Comment by Skeptic — June 10, 2011 @ 8:48 pm

  8. …Assuming of course Hitler had any knowledge of zyklon b, gas chambers, death camps, or a Final Solution.

    Comment by blair ericson — June 10, 2011 @ 3:46 pm

  9. Jerry Lewis made a movie that was never released about a clown who led children into the gas chambers. Here’s “The Day the Clown Cried” fan website with a wealth of information about this legendary movie, a clip of Jerry working on it plus news about the film’s cult following: http://www.subcin.com/clowncried.html

    From kubler-Ross’ Wikipedia entry:

    “In the late 1970s Kübler-Ross became interested in out-of-body experiences, mediumship, spiritualism and in other ways attempting to contact the dead. This led to a scandal connected to the Shanti Nilaya healing center where she was duped by the medium Jay Barham, founder of the Church of the Facet of the Divinity. Claiming he could channel the spirits of the departed and summon ethereal “entities”, he encouraged church members to engage in sexual relations with the “spirits”. He may have hired several women to play the parts of female spirits for this purpose. Kubler-Ross’ friend Deanna Edwards attended a service to ascertain whether allegations against Barham were true. He was found to be naked and wearing only a turban when Edwards unexpectedly pulled masking tape off the light switch and flipped on the light. Kubler-Ross may have thought that Christianity taught transmigration of the soul. “

    Comment by who+dares+wings — June 10, 2011 @ 9:58 am

    • Thanks for this information. I had never heard of the Clown movie. Perhaps Jerry Lewis got the idea from the story of Janusz Korczak who accompanied children from a Warsaw orphanage to Treblinka.

      I suspected that the name Kubler might have an umlaut. I will add the umlaut in my post.

      Comment by furtherglory — June 10, 2011 @ 10:17 am


RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

The Silver is the New Black Theme. Blog at WordPress.com.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 250 other followers

%d bloggers like this: